Should I Use a Realtor to Sell My House? Real Pros & Cons
Should I Use a Realtor to Sell My House? Real Pros & Cons
You wouldn't represent yourself in a major legal case without a law degree, and most of us don't file complex corporate taxes without an accountant. Selling your home is a similar high-stakes transaction, filled with legal requirements and negotiation strategies that can make or break your financial outcome. While going it alone might seem straightforward, the real estate market has its own set of rules and risks. The question "should I use a realtor to sell my house?" is about deciding if you want to learn a new profession overnight or hire a specialist whose entire career is dedicated to getting you the best result.
Key Takeaways
A Realtor's expertise directly impacts your bottom line: Their access to market data for accurate pricing, broad exposure via the MLS, and professional negotiation skills are all designed to secure a higher final sale price.
The FSBO path has hidden costs that can outweigh the savings: While you avoid paying a commission, FSBO homes often sell for less, and you'll still have to pay for marketing, photography, and legal advice, which can erase any potential savings.
The right agent more than pays for themselves: Instead of viewing the commission as a loss, consider it an investment. A skilled agent's ability to increase your home's sale price can cover their fee and put more money in your pocket.
Realtor vs. FSBO: Which Path Is Right for You?
Deciding whether to hire a real estate agent or sell your home yourself—known as For Sale By Owner, or FSBO—is one of the biggest choices you'll make in your selling journey. While the idea of saving on commission fees is tempting, it’s important to weigh that against the expertise, resources, and negotiation power a professional brings to the table. Let's break down what each path looks like so you can make the best decision for your situation.
What a Realtor Does to Sell Your House
A great real estate agent does much more than just put a sign in your yard. They are your project manager, marketer, and advocate from start to finish. Their job is to handle the heavy lifting so you can focus on your next move. An agent will manage everything from setting the right price using local market data to creating a comprehensive marketing plan. They also get your home on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), a powerful tool that sends your listing to popular sites like Zillow and Redfin, ensuring it reaches the widest possible audience. From there, they coordinate showings, vet potential buyers, and handle all the complex contracts and legal disclosures to protect you from issues down the road.
The Real Perks of Hiring a Realtor
Working with a Realtor isn't just about convenience; it's about achieving better results. The right agent provides tangible benefits that often lead to a smoother, more profitable sale. Because it’s easy to be emotionally attached to your home, an agent provides an objective, data-driven perspective to price it competitively from day one. Their access to the MLS and a professional network means more potential buyers see your home, which can lead to better offers. A seasoned agent has also negotiated hundreds of deals. They know how to handle tough conversations and counter-offers to protect your interests, a skill that can save you thousands. Ultimately, they manage the calls, showings, and endless questions, freeing up your time and reducing the stress of a major life transition.
The Other Side: Costs and Considerations
Of course, working with an agent comes with costs and requires a partnership built on trust. It's important to understand these factors before you sign a listing agreement. Realtors are paid a commission, which is a percentage of the home's final sale price. While this reduces your net proceeds, it's helpful to think of it as an investment in professional expertise that often leads to a higher sale price. When you hire an agent, you're also trusting them to guide the strategy, which means letting go of some control. This is why finding an agent whose communication style meshes with yours is so important. You need a proactive partner who keeps you informed every step of the way.
Going It Alone: Should You Sell Your House Yourself (FSBO)?
The FSBO route appeals to sellers who want maximum control and hope to save money by avoiding commission fees. While it can work for some, it's a path filled with significant challenges. The number one reason sellers choose FSBO is to avoid paying agent commissions, which is especially tempting if you already have a buyer lined up. However, the trade-off is a massive investment of your own time and energy. You're responsible for everything: pricing, marketing, legal paperwork, and negotiating. Statistics consistently show this lack of professional support has a financial downside—FSBO homes often sell for significantly less than agent-assisted homes, a gap that can easily exceed any commission savings.
The Financial Breakdown: Realtor vs. FSBO
When you look at the numbers, the decision becomes clearer. The goal is to achieve the highest possible net profit, not just to avoid a single expense. Data shows that homes sold with an agent typically sell for a higher price than FSBO homes. An agent's ability to price correctly, market broadly, and negotiate effectively creates competition among buyers, which drives the price up. As a FSBO seller, you'll also have your own costs, including professional photography, online listing fees, and attorney fees to review contracts. The commission you pay your agent is an investment in their expertise. If an agent can sell your home for more than you could on your own, their fee has more than paid for itself.
The Toughest Hurdles for FSBO Sellers
If you're considering the FSBO path, it's critical to be aware of the most common and difficult challenges you'll face. Pricing your home correctly is the most common stumbling block. Without access to the MLS and real-time market data, it's incredibly difficult to land on a price that's both competitive and profitable. You also limit your home's exposure, as most buyers find their homes online through sites fed by the MLS. Perhaps the biggest risk involves the paperwork. Real estate contracts are legally binding and full of complex clauses. Making a mistake or failing to provide a required disclosure can lead to a lawsuit or cause the entire deal to fall apart, making it one of the riskiest parts of selling without an expert.
Is a Realtor the Right Choice for You?
To figure out the best path forward, ask yourself a few honest questions. Your answers will help clarify whether you're truly prepared for a FSBO sale or if you'd be better served by a professional. How well do you know the local market and recent home sales in your neighborhood? Do you have the significant time and energy required to answer calls, host open houses, and manage all the administrative tasks? Are you aware of the current market conditions and how to adapt your strategy? Finally, are you a confident negotiator who can remain objective in high-stakes financial discussions with buyers and their experienced agents?
How to Choose the Right Realtor
If you've decided that working with an agent is the right move, the next step is finding the right one. Look for a professional who has a proven track record of success in your area. You need an agent with local market expertise who understands the nuances of Metro Detroit communities like Royal Oak, Ferndale, and Troy. Ask them to present a detailed marketing plan that includes professional photography and a strategy for getting your home in front of the right buyers. A trustworthy agent will also be transparent about their commission and services. The team at Jim Shaffer and Associates is built on integrity and a commitment to delivering unmatched results for every client.
Related Articles
Real Estate Broker vs Realtor: Who Should You Hire? — Jim Shaffer And Associates
How to Find the Best Realtor to Sell My House — Jim Shaffer And Associates
Top 3 Things To Know When Selling a Home — Jim Shaffer And Associates
Frequently Asked Questions
Isn't the main point of selling my own home to save money on commission? While saving on commission is the number one reason people choose to sell their own homes, it's important to focus on your net profit—the final amount you walk away with. Data consistently shows that homes sold with an agent sell for a significantly higher price than those sold by owners. An agent's expertise in pricing, marketing, and negotiation often creates a bidding environment that more than covers the cost of their commission, ultimately putting more money in your pocket.
What if I already have someone who wants to buy my house? Do I still need a Realtor? This is a great position to be in, but having a professional in your corner is still incredibly valuable. An agent will ensure the price you've discussed is fair market value, so you don't leave money on the table. They also manage the entire transaction, from navigating inspections and appraisals to handling the complex legal paperwork, protecting you from potential liabilities and ensuring the deal closes smoothly.
What are the biggest risks if I handle the sale myself? The three biggest hurdles for FSBO sellers are pricing, marketing, and legal paperwork. Without access to the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and real-time market data, it's very difficult to price your home correctly, which can cause it to sit on the market or sell for too little. You also miss out on the massive exposure an agent provides. Most importantly, real estate contracts are legally binding and complex. A simple mistake or missed disclosure can lead to a lawsuit or cause the sale to fall through completely.
Can't I just hire an attorney to handle the contracts and do the rest on my own? While an attorney is essential for reviewing legal documents, their role is very different from a real estate agent's. An attorney won't help you price your home, develop a marketing strategy, schedule showings, or negotiate offers and repairs. A real estate agent acts as your project manager for the entire process, handling dozens of tasks that fall outside the scope of legal review to ensure you get the best possible outcome.
How do I know if an agent is the right fit for me? Finding the right agent is about finding a true partner. Look for a professional with a strong, verifiable track record in your specific neighborhood. They should present you with a clear, comprehensive marketing plan and be able to explain exactly how they'll price your home. Most importantly, choose someone you communicate well with. You want an agent who is responsive, transparent, and makes you feel confident and supported from start to finish.
